
(almost a century ago!).
It's since been played, sung and recorded by untold numbers of vocalists and instrumentalists (both known and unknown) and their grannys (literally - so to speak).
Why? Because it's a great song with a simple, memorable, singable melody with hip lyrics (considered to be somewhat risqué at the time it was recorded).
The 5-note repeating melodic phrase of the tune's first three bars are iconic. It's become a standard melodic device for generations of improvisers and worth a closer peek.
When you look at it, the simplicity of this little 5-note melodic "hook" is both striking and satisfying at the same time. With the C Major numbered note placement being 5-4 (descending) then 6-1-3 (ascending - an A min triad) we're given a slick, simple and original way of expressing melody, tonality and rhythm - and worth repeating. This held true in 1929, 2025, and all times in between. Thank you, Fats!
Ex. #1 - The first 4 bars of "Honeysuckle Rose", transposed to C major.
Case and point - Ex. #2. Using the same basic 5-note "Honeysuckle" shape, we can fashion something we might even dare to call our own. Looking at the first measure, the initial 5-notes are the same except for... the Ab, which has been lowered a half-step from the original in order to facilitate the melody in fitting with the D min7b5, an altered form of the original ii chord - the Ab in this case being the b5.
The extra D in the first measure belongs to the 6th mode of F Melodic Minor (D Locrian #2), from which D min7b5 is derived. The shape continues with a Bb (the #9 of G7alt) anticipated on the "and" of four, creating #9-b9 & 3-b13-1; the first two notes descending, with the latter three ascending in the form of a B Augmented triad. A slight variation in shape takes place in bar #3, with the 3rd and 4th notes changing places, relative to the original.
Ex. # - A 4-bar ii-V7-I with "Honeysuckle" shapes in bars 1, 2 and 3.
(sniff...) Ahhhhh!!
B. Stern
*** The Daily BoopaDoop - "LuLu's Back in Town" ***
*** "Airegin" - Six Short Etudes - First Eight of the First Ending ***
*** Joe Henderson's "Black Narcissus" - The Last Eight ***